The twelfth and latest of the Jack Reacher novels by Lee Child. As usual, this tale finds Jack dragged into another situation where life and death are on the line and the bad guys are trying to keep him away from the truth.

Jack finds himself between two remote towns in Colorado: Hope and Despair. Despair being on his route he heads in to town to grab a bite to eat and to find a place to stay for the night. Instead, he is arrested, charged with vagrancy and deposited on the town border with instructions to go back to Hope. Intrigued and angry he decides to investigate and finds a lot that doesn’t add up - a town that is entirely owned by one man, a populace who seem happy to be owned and will fight to keep it that way and young women arriving secretly and leaving secretly looking for their men. In the end he will be forced to make hard decisions and risk it all.

Pretty much par for the course in any of these novels, Reacher is always one man against the machine. He is a likeable character, pretty near invulnerable, just smart enough to be one of us and just dumb enough to not be an out and out genius. The story has plenty of action and plenty of mystery to make it engaging and fun to read. I suppose.

So what went wrong? Reading the novel felt like a bit of a struggle to me. In places it almost seemed like it wasn’t part of the loose series. There isn’t any one thing I could put my finger on: there are lots of points in the story where Reacher is asked to take a look at himself and see what others see - on older man, scruffy, weather beaten with no home or belongings. While Child put the same energy into the fight scenes, Reacher seemed tired. Possibly, and I may be reading too much into it, Child is wearying of the character - maybe the author needs to take a break and/or write about a new character.

This isn’t enough to turn me off the series, overall they are just far too much fun to read. Reacher is the approachable loner, the maverick who cares about everybody if he meets them for more than a few minutes. If you are new to the series, don’t read this first - it deals with bigger events than those in the towns and these don’t always translate well to thsi character - pick up one of the earlier novels and start from there.

2 Comments

  1. I have just finished reading the novel, and I feel it is one of the best I have read! And I guess exactly because of the things you mentioned! This time Reacher is wrong a couple of times, he even regrets diverting to Despair. Of course he wins every fight (anything else would have been really disappointing), but he has in fact grown older. The young girls aren’t attracted to him anymore, and Reacher knows it. Maybe he’s growing weary, maybe he’s just growing wiser… And I liked the political implications about the war in Iraq. It’s not the hooray-patriotism (is there such a word in English?) of earlier novels, it’s more of what one would expect from an ex-soldier who knows what’s going on.
    I agree that you shouldn’t start reading the Reacher-novels with this one. But I think in moves in the right direction. Reacher is becoming a person again after being just a hero in a few of the former books.
    There is a “but” to this of course: But is it still Reacher then? I don’t know. Let’s see…

  2. I always saw reacher as a Batman-like character - he has no special powers, just his training and experience and knowledge. While some introspection is good for fictional heroes, I miss the Reacher who knows exactly what he’s doing and how he’ll do it. This one just didn’t feel right to me….

One Trackback/Pingback

  1. By Lee Child: Nothing to Lose (Teil 2) « Planet9 on 23 Apr 2008 at 12:43 pm

    [...] Gedanken als in früheren Romanen. Meiner Meinung nach schadet das nicht, aber das kann man auch anders sehen… Meine Lieblingsszene ist die, in der es ums Rasieren geht (bewußt so schwammig [...]

Post a Comment

*
*